OTTERBEIN AT MAINEVILLE

201 MARGE SCHOTT WAY, MAINEVILLE, OH 45039 · CCN 366393 · 60 certified beds · Data as of 2026-07-01

CMS overall3 of 5CMS inspections3 of 5CMS staffing4 of 5CMS quality4 of 5

Star ratings are issued by CMS (the federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services), not by NursingHomeLens. We report them; we do not rate or rank facilities.

State inspectors recorded 1 immediate-jeopardy citation(s) here in the last three years — CMS's most serious level.

Get the full report Watch this facility

Serious inspection findings

2025-12-16 — ACTUAL HARM (tag F0805, severity G)

Nutrition and Dietary Deficiencies · correction not recorded in CMS data

Ensure each resident receives and the facility provides food prepared in a form designed to meet individual needs.

2025-05-16 — IMMEDIATE JEOPARDY (tag F0689, severity K)

Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies · correction not recorded in CMS data

Ensure that a nursing home area is free from accident hazards and provides adequate supervision to prevent accidents.

2024-02-06 — ACTUAL HARM (tag F0689, severity G)

Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies · correction not recorded in CMS data

Ensure that a nursing home area is free from accident hazards and provides adequate supervision to prevent accidents.

Staffing, from payroll records

Nursing hours / resident / day

4.29

state median 3.20

Weekend staffing gap

+2%

more nursing hours on weekends · state median −4%

RN hours / resident / day

0.55

registered nurses only

Contract (agency) staff

share of all nursing hours

Nursing staff turnover

60%

per year, per CMS

Source: CMS Payroll-Based Journal, 2026Q1, 90 reported days — actual payroll data, not the facility's own estimates.

Keep an eye on this facility

Monitoring alerts are launching soon: new citations, penalties, ownership changes, and staffing drops for facilities you follow. Leave your email and we'll notify you when it goes live for OTTERBEIN AT MAINEVILLE.

Penalties and enforcement

2 enforcement action(s), totaling $26,169 in fines.

Date	Type	Amount
2025-04-03	Fine	$17,345
2024-02-06	Fine	$8,824

Ownership

Ownership type: Non profit - Corporation. Part of the OTTERBEIN SENIORLIFE chain.

Other facilities under the same ownership, with their CMS overall ratings:

OTTERBEIN FRANKLIN SENIORLIFE COMM RES & COM CARE (FRANKLIN, IN) — CMS overall2 of 5
OTTERBEIN LEBANON RETIREMENT COMMUNITY (LEBANON, OH) — CMS overall5 of 5
GREEN HILLS CENTER (WEST LIBERTY, OH) — CMS overall3 of 5
OTTERBEIN PORTAGE VALLEY (PEMBERVILLE, OH) — CMS overall4 of 5
OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY (ST MARYS, OH) — CMS overall4 of 5
OTTERBEIN-CRIDERSVILLE (CRIDERSVILLE, OH) — CMS overall3 of 5
OTTERBEIN SUNSET HOUSE (TOLEDO, OH) — CMS overall3 of 5
OTTERBEIN SUNSET VILLAGE (SYLVANIA, OH) — CMS overall2 of 5

Full citation history

By severity: No harm, potential for minimal harm: 2 · Actual harm: 2 · Potential for more than minimal harm: 27 · Immediate jeopardy: 1

Survey date	Tag	Category	Severity	Corrected
2025-12-16	F0805	Nutrition and Dietary Deficiencies	G	not recorded
2025-05-16	F0584	Resident Rights Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2025-05-16	F0689	Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies	K	not recorded
2025-04-03	F0584	Resident Rights Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2025-04-03	F0623	Resident Rights Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2025-04-03	F0625	Resident Rights Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2025-04-03	F0641	Resident Assessment and Care Planning Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2025-04-03	F0777	Administration Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2025-04-03	F0791	Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2025-04-03	F0812	Nutrition and Dietary Deficiencies	F	not recorded
2024-12-18	F0690	Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2024-11-06	F0550	Resident Rights Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2024-11-06	F0580	Resident Rights Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2024-11-06	F0880	Infection Control Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2024-02-06	F0580	Resident Rights Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2024-02-06	F0689	Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies	G	not recorded
2024-02-06	F0776	Administration Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2022-06-02	F0623	Resident Rights Deficiencies	B	not recorded
2022-06-02	F0641	Resident Assessment and Care Planning Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2022-06-02	F0692	Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2019-04-18	F0583	Resident Rights Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2019-04-18	F0623	Resident Rights Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2019-04-18	F0625	Resident Rights Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2019-04-18	F0657	Resident Assessment and Care Planning Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2019-04-18	F0692	Quality of Life and Care Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2019-04-18	F0730	Nursing and Physician Services Deficiencies	C	not recorded
2019-04-18	F0758	Pharmacy Service Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2019-04-18	F0761	Pharmacy Service Deficiencies	E	not recorded
2019-04-18	F0803	Nutrition and Dietary Deficiencies	E	not recorded
2019-04-18	F0812	Nutrition and Dietary Deficiencies	E	not recorded
2019-04-18	F0842	Resident Assessment and Care Planning Deficiencies	D	not recorded
2019-04-18	F0880	Infection Control Deficiencies	D	not recorded

Sources: CMS Provider Information, Health Deficiencies, Penalties, and Ownership datasets (data.cms.gov/provider-data), processed 2026-07-01; CMS Payroll-Based Journal daily staffing. Find this facility on Care Compare: search “OTTERBEIN AT MAINEVILLE, MAINEVILLE” at medicare.gov/care-compare.